Loading the lesson
Loading the lesson
Search AllRounder.ai
Search the courses, subjects, tracks, games and features, or jump straight to a page.
Search the courses, subjects, tracks, games and features, or jump straight to a page.
Learn it your way
A short class with Sarah and her students. The other ways are under More.
Sign up free to listen. Transcripts are free to read.
In Chapter 18 we heard Mayella. What changes when Tom Robinson takes the stand, Student_1?
We hear the other version of the evening. Tom says he often helped her with chores and that she invited him in.
Why did Tom help her without being paid, Student_2?
He says he felt sorry for her because she seemed to have so much to do.
And what does he say happened inside the house?
That she made advances to him, and that he ran when her father appeared at the window shouting.
Notice how steady and consistent his account is, even though he is the one whose life is at stake.
What does Tom say that makes the courtroom react?
That he felt sorry for Mayella.
Why is that shocking to the white community of Maycomb?
Because a Black man was not supposed to feel pity for a white woman. It suggests that he sees himself as above her.
What does that reaction show about the courtroom?
That people care more about the racial order than about whether Tom is telling the truth.
And what is Dill's reaction?
He cries, because he can see that Tom is being treated unfairly and he cannot hide it the way the adults do.
Tom's account contradicts the Ewells' story, and the jury must decide whom to believe.
Tom's crippled left arm becomes physical evidence against the State's version.
Tom's steadiness contrasts with the prosecutor's contempt.
Tom's honest statement breaks the racial code and damages him.
Dill's tears show an untaught sense of fairness.
Example of irony: Tom is judged harshly for kindness and honesty, the very qualities that should make him credible.
Example of contrast: Atticus's courtesy towards Mayella in Chapter 18 compares with Mr. Gilmer's contempt for Tom in this chapter.
Example of a child's reaction as moral commentary: Dill cannot hide his distress, although the adults around him say nothing.
Tom told it calm and Tom told it true, but the court looked at colour and not at what he knew.
Imagine a scale with two pans. On one is a calm man with a crippled arm and an honest story. On the other is a crowd's habit of prejudice. The chapter shows which way the courtroom leans, and it makes Dill cry.
Remember T.O.M. for the chapter: Truthful account, Obvious contempt, Moving reaction from Dill.
P.I.T.Y. - Prejudice in the cross-examination, Injured arm as evidence, Tom's steady account, Young Dill's tears
Term
Who testifies in Chapter 19?
Click to flip
Term
What physical detail about Tom matters as evidence?
Click to flip
Term
Why does Tom say he helped Mayella?
Click to flip
Term
Why does the courtroom react badly to this?
Click to flip
Term
Who breaks down in tears, and why?
Click to flip
A solemn promise to tell the truth, made by a witness before giving testimony in court.
The statements a witness makes under oath in a trial.
Questioning of a witness by the opposing side to test the truth of the account.
The unwritten rules of conduct that forced Black and white people in Maycomb into unequal roles.
A feeling that a person is beneath consideration, shown here in the prosecutor's manner towards Tom.
Calm self-respect, shown by Tom even while he is treated unfairly.
A gap between what should happen and what does, such as an honest, kind witness being punished for his honesty and kindness.
Chapter 19 of 'To Kill a Mockingbird' gives the witness stand to Tom Robinson, whose calm account contradicts the Ewells' story. His honest statement that he felt sorry for Mayella and the prosecutor's contemptuous questioning show how deeply race shapes what the courtroom is prepared to hear.
Tom Robinson takes the oath and tells the court that he often helped Mayella Ewell with chores as he passed her house, without payment, because he felt sorry for her. He says that on the evening in question she invited him in and made advances, and that he ran in fear when her father appeared at the window and shouted abuse. Mr. Gilmer cross-examines him with open contempt. When Tom admits that he felt sorry for Mayella, the courtroom reacts as if he has broken a rule, because pity from a Black man towards a white woman defies the racial code of Maycomb. Dill is so upset by the way Tom is treated that he breaks down in tears, and Scout takes him outside.
Chapter 19 gives the witness stand to the accused. After hearing the Ewells, the court listens to Tom Robinson's own account of the evening, and the contrast between the two versions is the heart of the trial. The chapter also shows, through the prosecutor's cross-examination and the courtroom's reaction, how thoroughly race shapes what the court is prepared to hear.
A witness the reader sees clearly. As Tom takes the oath, the narration draws attention to his crippled left arm. The detail matters as evidence, because the injuries described earlier in the trial were on one side of Mayella's face, and Tom's disability makes the State's version of events harder to believe. It also shapes the reader's feelings before Tom has said a word: he is a man marked by a hard life and yet steady and dignified.
Tom's account. Questioned by Atticus, Tom says that he often passed the Ewell house on his way to and from work and that Mayella had several times asked him to help with small jobs. He did them without payment because he felt sorry for her and thought she had too much to do. On the evening in question she invited him into the house. Once he was inside, she made advances to him, and when her father appeared at the window and shouted abuse at her, Tom ran out of fear. He denies that he hurt her or attacked her. His account is simple and consistent, and it reverses the accusation: if it is true, the person who behaved improperly was Mayella, and the person who reacted violently was her father.
The cross-examination. Mr. Gilmer questions Tom with contempt. He speaks to him in a belittling way, tries to suggest that Tom is strong and dangerous, and presses him on why he ran. Tom answers steadily and explains that he was frightened. The prosecutor's manner shows that, for him, Tom's word counts for little before it has even been spoken. The contrast with Atticus's courteous treatment of Mayella in the previous chapter could hardly be sharper.
The answer that damages him. Under pressure, Tom says that he helped Mayella because he felt sorry for her. The courtroom reacts. In Maycomb's racial code a Black man was not supposed to feel pity for a white woman, since pity suggested that he considered himself above her. Mr. Gilmer seizes on the answer, and the reaction of the court shows that people are less concerned with whether Tom is truthful than with whether he has kept to the place the white community has given him. Tom's honesty and kindness have been turned against him.
Dill's tears. Dill, watching from the balcony, cannot bear the way Tom is spoken to, and he begins to cry. Scout takes him out of the courtroom. The child's reaction invites the reader to ask what has happened to the instinct for fairness in the adults around him. It also leads directly into the events of Chapter 20.
What the chapter shows. Chapter 19 is the emotional turning point of the trial. The reader has heard a calm, consistent account from a man with a crippled arm and has watched the court respond not with attention to the evidence but with discomfort at a Black man's pity for a white woman. The chapter sharpens the question that hangs over the rest of the trial: will twelve white jurors judge the evidence, or will they defend the racial order?